Aug 31, 2009
F for Fake
This is Orson Welles’s masterpiece, a virtuoso performance of sound and video editing that co-opts the documentary but is not one. It is the rare postmodern text that’s laugh out loud funny, steeped in the relativism of the post war period but not held hostage by it. He appears as himself, sheared of doubts and humanity, in full possession and knowledge of his genius, but he is not the subject (excuse my language) of the film. It’s a “film about trickery, fraud and lies,” and about two great exponents of those arts, Elmyr de Hory and Clifford Irving. The film is not much watched by people from any generation, met with cold critical reception on release, how can it be Welles’s masterpiece? But it is, and is neglected due to its translation from the dross and palaver of our late capitalist society in which relativism extends mainly to the comparison of ledgers, a number of hard, unpleasant truths about meaning, about value, and about our modern oracles, the experts. Or as Welles says of art (or anything): “How is it valued? The value depends on opinion. Opinion depends on the expert. A faker like Elmyr makes fools of the experts, so who’s the expert? Who’s the faker?”




Too true. “F for Fake” is what you watch when you get bored of “Citizen Kane.” Don’t know if you’ve seen it, but Orson Welles edited a nine-minute preview that has nothing (yet everything) to do with the movie:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNyvg4s3YMA
yeah, it’s on the criterion double disc version that i bought, sight unseen, while browsing the dvds at some store when i was like fifteen. i watched the movie once, didn’t get it and put it on the shelf, then randomly rewatched it junior year and became obsessed by it. i’ve probably seen it 80-100 times…
I finished this about thirty minutes ago and it is absolutely fantastic. There’s a fresh idea every two seconds, roughly.
[...] Temple is on board to direct the film adaptation of Clifford Irving’s Fake!, his book about F for Fake subject Elmyr de Hory. This is good news if it gets more people to watch the Welles [...]