Apr 5, 2010
I Survived a Taping of American Idol

I was once a thirteen-year-old girl. But I wasn’t very good at it, because I loathed boy bands and read too many comic books. Recently, though, at the resolutely adult age of 24, I was given a chance to redeem myself at a taping of an American Idol episode. If you’re pressed for time and can’t read through this whole article, my experience can be summed up in one event: I touched Justin Bieber’s hand.
This unlikely scene was made possible when a law school friend extended the invitation to me and two of our classmates. As we were herded from the CBS studio lot to the audience pit, we experienced the singular discomfort of being four grown women standing in a pack of screaming ‘tweens. Fortunately, we were prompted into a thirteen-year-old frame of mind by two voices from our past: guest-starring on this episode of “American Idol” were Usher, who may have single-handedly kickstarted my puberty, and Diddy, once known to me as “Puff Daddy.” If I began the show by standing with my arms crossed like a jaded old hipster, the first sight of Usher’s strut had me dancing in a circle of girls like it was eighth grade graduation.
The on-air portions of Idol were surprisingly brief, considering were at the studio for seven hours. A pretty, unmemorable contestant was eliminated from the competition and wept during an awkward group hug that suggested schadenfreude more than real sympathy. Ryan Seacrest postured and preened irritatingly, having used up his quota of “boyish charm” years ago. Heads swiveled to watch him snipping back and forth with Simon Cowell like sorority sisters who have lived together for too long. “This isn’t the Oprah Winfrey show,” bitched Simon, after Seacrest asked him how an inexperienced teenager might be able to convincingly deliver a love song. “I’m going to ask you because you’re a judge and this is your highly paid job,” Seacrest retorted through a brittle smile. Ooooh, the all-female pit audience said in unison.

Of course, seeing American Idol live bore no resemblance to the tidy version that airs on national television. So many priceless moments go unseen by TV viewers. There are the bizarre rules: dress in “trendy, upscale” darks; clap with your hands above your head; do not hug Justin Bieber. There are awkward and unscripted moments: an overcome fan bum-rushing the stage to hug Bieber in violation of Bizarre Rule #3, Usher doing a second take of his single “OMG” because the crowd wasn’t adequately pumped the first time, a fifteen-minute search for the fedora Usher tossed into the crowd during his first try. There are long periods of standing around and watching the antics of non-celebrities: backup dancers adjusting their bras, a hype-man with a not-coincidental resemblance to Seacrest giving away the occasional iTouch, security guards admonishing the pit audience that an attempt to hug Bieber would result in “going to jail, like, forever, okay?”
The show ended in a “pre-tape” of Bieber performing a medley of his songs, which would be aired during the next episode. Before the performance, stagehands strategically arranged girls from the audience pit on the steps leading to the stage—the better for Bieber to dole out soulful gazes and handshakes. (See my first paragraph.) Upon hearing the first bar of music, the girl beside me screamed and clutched her chest alarmingly. Others followed suit. I sensed that this is what I had been missing during my middle school years when I declined to accompany my friends to see *NSYNC in concert.

My friends and I tried to get into the spirit of teenage frenzy by dancing and screaming, but we were outed as twenty-somethings twice. The first moment occurred when our catcalls stretched the boundaries of PG-13, earning us a raised eyebrow from the closest security guard. More representative commentary consisted of “I love you, Justin!” and “Oh my God, you’re hot!” We also gave away our ages by being the only girls in the audience pit who could not sing along to every single lyric. And through all of this, Bieber smiled awkwardly and flipped his bangs fetchingly. By the time the performance began, his stage entourage included a troupe of hip-hop dancers, backup singers, a live band, a DJ, and pyrotechnics accompanied by a drum solo.
During one commercial break, the generic hype-man threw out glow-pop rings, which were inexplicably greeted with the same enthusiasm as the free iTouch. A mother with a ‘tween in tow muttered, “Maybe they have Bieber’s baby teeth in them.” At that point, one of my law school friends captured the tenor of the night perfectly: “It’s crazy—I identify more with the moms here than their daughters!”


