Jonathan Pope

Dahlia Lithwick’s recent piece on “the sad state of the liberal law student” is rehash of an article written four hundred times in the past year about how the confirmation process and the media and whomever else have made any non-Scaliaesque school of constitutional interpretation allegedly radical. That’s true and awful. But repeating that and trying to make it about students undercuts the actual issues around conservatism and progressiveness that liberal law students should be sad about.
Aysha Pamukcu

There are the bizarre rules: dress in “trendy, upscale” darks; clap with your hands above your head; do not hug Justin Bieber. There are awkward and unscripted moments: an overcome fan bum-rushing the stage to hug Bieber in violation of Bizarre Rule #3, Usher doing a second take of his single “OMG” because the crowd wasn’t adequately pumped the first time, a fifteen-minute search for the fedora Usher tossed into the crowd during his first try.
Kevin Hilke

The immediate reaction from the Republican National Committee to the passage of the historic healthcare bill Sunday night, ostensibly penned by Chairman Michael Steele and intended for the party faithful, is a gracefully deranged gem of ad hominem missives. Now that the Republican propaganda campaign to “kill the bill” has proven unsuccessful, the GOP’s sole substantive response is a fundraising gimmick centered on convincing Americans that the Speaker of the House is one colossal B.
Kevin Hilke

David Milch’s Deadwood lays bare the dynamic and discursive construction of subjective experience with unrivaled felicity, clarity, and skill. Milch’s characters emerge, shimmer, and recede too frenetically for us to pull back and examine them as complex wholes. We are instead absolutely stuck, with Deadwood’s inhabitants, in a state of constant, potent experiential flux. Radical contingency reigns, making moments of inexplicable terror and moments of astonishing grace equally likely and equally unpredictable.
Eric Freeman

How has a teenager in America never heard a Jay-Z song? No one will ever mistake Miley Cyrus’s bizarre concoction of country, pop, and Spears-style pre-legal come-ons for hip-hop, but her music occupies the same cultural sphere as Jay-Z. These are songs that people know. If she were a normal girl, she’d be going to Jay-Z concerts with her friends.